I've not shopped at either, being normally paranoid about the smallest of details as well when shopping online. What's most important to me is communication with the seller. If you're still looking around, try checking out
I don't see Hitman Reborn listed on the site, but what I love about the seller is, if she doesn't have it, odds are she'll get it or make it just for you. Her prices are the same or lower than most places I've been (though 3.99 is hard to beat). The quality of the things I've bought from her so far are better than what a bargain hunter like myself can ask for.
email her at: email@example.com with reference pictures of what you're looking for. she's very friendly
you'll get a reply in a day. She's based in China so keep in mind the hours. Right now it's 3:17pm for me and her status on the website is online.
This post has been edited by code2destroy: 09 January 2012 - 03:19 PM